Pros 
Cons A Legendary Reputation in Meat Craftsmanship
Mathews Artisan Butchers has carved a name for itself in the Flemington community and beyond, boasting an impressive rating of 4.9 out of 5. Established by Matthew, a third-generation butcher, this shop combines traditional techniques with modern culinary trends, evident in its premium product offerings. Customers frequently express their admiration for Matthew’s expertise, often saying:
“Matthew is an expert at what he does. He is not just selling meat; he’s sharing his passion.”
The shop doesn't just stop at meat; it also extends into complementary offerings that include wines and gourmet delicacies, making it a one-stop shop for meal preparation. Many visitors have praised the diverse inventory, such as:
- Amazing Wagyu and Scotch Fillet: Renowned for its rich flavor.
- Prepared Olives and Spicy Pork Sausages: Regulars claim these are among the best they have tasted, with numerous customers echoing, “The best sausages I’ve ever had.”
Such high-quality offerings have solidified Mathews Artisan Butchers as a go-to destination for anyone serious about their meat.
Exceptional Customer Service with a Personal Touch
At Mathews Artisan Butchers, the experience goes beyond purchasing meat; it’s about community and connection. Matthew and his team are known for their friendly, helpful demeanor and willingness to offer advice. Whether you’re a seasoned chef or a home cook, customers have shared glowing feedback about their interactions, such as:
- Personal Recommendations: Matthew is always eager to suggest cuts, saying, "Speak to me about what else can be purchased outside of what’s available in the window."
- Welcoming Atmosphere: The team is lauded for creating a warm environment, often greeting returning customers with smiles and engaging conversations.
The accessibility features of the shop—like wheelchair-accessible entrances and parking—further demonstrate their commitment to customer satisfaction, ensuring everyone feels welcomed and valued.
Quality to Savor and Enjoy
Quality is the hallmark of Mathews Artisan Butchers, drawing discerning customers from afar who are willing to pay a premium for meat that exceeds supermarket standards. Frequent patrons highlight the following aspects of their shopping experience:
- Artisanal Quality: The cuts are carefully selected, dry-aged to perfection, and butchered with precision, leading to rave reviews:
- “The dry-aged rib eye cooked beautifully on the chargrill.”
- Supporting Local: As a family-owned business, the butcher shop provides a sense of authenticity that reflects the values of the community.
- Gourmet Options: Aside from meat, the shop features an array of top-notch wines and cheese, catering to those looking to elevate their dining experiences.
Customers often remark that while the prices may be higher than conventional supermarkets, they believe it’s well worth the investment, reinforcing the motto that if you are going to eat meat, “eat quality, even if that does mean less frequently.”
Creating Culinary Memories
Mathews Artisan Butchers is not just about selling meat; it’s about crafting culinary memories that last a lifetime. Many have shared their experiences of using the shop's premium products for special occasions, with testimonials highlighting spectacular results:
- Holiday Feasts: One customer raved, “We got a ham on the bone and turkey for Christmas. Everyone said it was the best they ever had.”
- Dinner Parties: Customers have noted that having Mathews' high-quality meats has transformed their gatherings into exquisite affairs.
Notably, the shop’s aesthetic adds to the experience. With a beautifully presented layout and a captivating atmosphere—a salt wall in the dry aging room, for instance—the establishment encourages relaxation and enjoyment while shopping.
In conclusion, Mathews Artisan Butchers stands out as a beacon of quality, service, and community connection in the Flemington area. Its passionate dedication to providing exquisite products and enhancing customer experience ensures that this butcher shop will thrive, earning praises for doing what they love, the right way.